The U.S. and Israel Diverge Sharply on Iran - TheDispatch Online

Breaking

Home Top Ad

Post Top Ad

Friday, 15 July 2022

The U.S. and Israel Diverge Sharply on Iran


Prime Minister Yair Lapid of Israel called on the United States to threaten military action if Iran continued its nuclear program, while President Biden said diplomacy was the best way to counter threats from Iran


By Our Foreign CORRESPONDENT                               Published, Friday, July 15, 2022


JERUSALEM — Israel’s caretaker prime minister, Yair Lapid, pushed President Biden on Thursday to go beyond his public commitment to stopping Iran from ever obtaining a nuclear weapon, declaring that all democratic nations must vow to act if the Iranians continue “to develop their nuclear program.”

The distinction between Mr. Biden’s commitment and Mr. Lapid’s declaration was more than semantic: It goes to the heart of their countries’ differing approaches in dealing with Iran’s nuclear ambitions. Israel has conducted a series of covert sabotage and assassination operations  to slow Iran’s ability to enrich nuclear fuel, while Mr. Biden has insisted that diplomacy, and a restoration of the 2015 Iran nuclear agreement, are the best way to find a permanent solution.

“If they continue to develop their nuclear program, the free world will use force,” Mr. Lapid said at the opening of a news conference in Jerusalem after the two leaders met as part of Mr. Biden’s four-day visit to the Middle East. During those remarks, Mr. Biden listened attentively but never repeated that commitment. Instead, he stuck to talking about blocking Iran from obtaining a weapon — not a program that might be intended to develop one.

In the short news conference, Mr. Biden was pressed directly on whether he would raise the case of a murdered Saudi dissident, Jamal Khashoggi, when he meets with Saudi leaders on Friday. Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman was deemed responsible for the brutal 2018 killing in Istanbul of Mr. Khashoggi, a columnist for The Washington Post who was living in the United States.

Mr. Biden said on Thursday that his views on the murder were well-known — but he stopped short of saying whether he would specifically raise the dissident’s name during his meeting.

“My views on Khashoggi have been absolutely, positively clear,” Mr. Biden said, adding that he had never hesitated to speak openly to allies and adversaries about human rights. But with the American leader scheduled to fly directly from Israel to Jeddah on Friday — a flight that itself says much about the changed environment in the M middle East — administration officials were still debating how, if at all, he should raise the case in public comments on Saudi soil.

In other cases, recently including Cuba and Venezuela, Mr. Biden has stressed that his administration is making democracy and respect for human rights the paramount consideration for dealing with other nations’ leaders. But on Thursday in Jerusalem he said, “the reason I am going to Saudi Arabia is to promote U.S. interests,” which include getting the kingdom to pump more oil from its somewhat modest spare capacity.

Mr. Biden’s news conference with Mr. Lapid was the only scheduled set of extensive remarks on his trip to the Middle East. He used it to bolster the blossoming relationship between Israel and a handful of Arab states, including the creation of a joint air defense zone to protect against Iranian drones and missiles. Administration officials say that while they are pushing for full diplomatic relations between Saudi Arabia and Israel, they expect only incremental progress toward that goal on this trip.

He said that he had been impressed by a demonstration on Wednesday of Israelis and Americans using the Iron Dome rocket-interception system, and a new system named Iron Beam, still a prototype, that uses lasers. 

“These technologies and advances are critical, Mr. Biden said. “Every rocket that is intercepted is a potential life, maybe more, that is saved.”


Speaking Together Biden and Lapid, Revealing Their Diving Line on Iran

JERUSALEM — Israel is increasingly embedded within the diplomatic ecosystem of the Middle East after several landmark deals brokered by the Trump administration that normalized relations between Israel and three other Arab states: Bahrain, Morocco and the United Arab Emirates.

And on Thursday, Prime Minister Yair Lapid suggested that Israel was ready to normalize diplomatic relations with more Arab nations — including Saudi Arabia.

Speaking at a news conference in Jerusalem one day before President Biden was scheduled to fly to Saudi Arabia for events, including a summit of a group known as the Gulf Cooperation Council, Mr. Lapid told him, “Mr. President, you will meet with the leaders of Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Kuwait, Oman and Iraq.” He added: “I would like you to pass them all a message from us: Our hand is outstretched for peace.”

“We are ready to share our technology and experience, ready for our people to meet and learn about one another, ready for our scientists to collaborate and our businesses to cooperate,” Mr. Lapid said.

Mr. Biden also hinted at the news conference that he was pushing for normalized relations between Israel and Saudi Arabia. “When I see the Saudi leadership tomorrow, I’ll be carrying a direct message — a message of peace,” Mr. Biden said.

Historically, Saudi officials have said that they would avoid a formal relationship with Israel until the creation of a Palestinian state. But leading Saudis have become increasingly critical of the Palestinian leadership, and two Saudi commentators expressed support for normalization with Israel in recent days.

The Israeli news media has also reported on back-channel negotiations to increase the number of Israeli planes allowed to fly over the Saudi mainland, and to secure Israel’s blessing to change the role of international peacekeepers on two strategic small islands near Israel’s southern coast that Egypt handed over to Saudi Arabia in 2017. An Israeli minister, Esawi Frej, also said Israel had asked Riyadh to allow pilgrims from Israel’s Muslim minority to fly directly from Israel to the kingdom.

“There is new closeness between Israel and the Gulf,” said Itamar Rabinovich, a former Israeli ambassador to Washington. “The question is: Can the United States try to take all these different bricks and build something new with them?”

Mr. Lapid’s and Mr. Biden’s comments followed their signing of a joint declaration, which said that the United States was committed to expanding Israel’s regional integration, including in the context of Mr. Biden’s visit to Saudi Arabia.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Post Bottom Ad